Review: thumbs down for the DIRECTV satellite Internet offer
Posted by Dennis Sellers
Jan 22, 2007 at 1:17pm
Okay, I’ve never “reviewed” a product I haven’t actually used before, so this is a first. In fact, this is more of a rant/vent than a review per se, but … well, read on, and you’ll see what I mean.
As Macsimum readers know, I’ve been running this web site on dial-up for three years now (no really, I do). But we’ve grown so much that what was once an aggravating inconvenience is now unacceptable. My problem: I live on a road that’s less than a mile from a major mall in Nashville, Tennessee, but neither the phone company nor cable company will implement DSL or cable Internet on our road. You see, Luster Road is almost a mile long with only a dozen or so houses, so providing residents on it isn’t cost effective, the companies say.
I was very excited when I received a flyer in the mail on Jan. 13 that said that DIRECTV was now offering a satellite TV/satellite Internet bundle in “my neighborhood” (their words). However, when I called to get details, I was told that DIRECTV doesn’t implement satellite Internet where I live. Which is nuts. They’re not stringing cable or telephone lines. We’re talking about installing a dish, for crying out loud. So why is it that I can’t get satellite Internet, exactly? I wrote DIRECTTV and here’s the vague answer I got:
“Thanks for your interest in broadband Internet service from DIRECTV. I’m sorry for the frustrations this issue may have caused you. We started offering a new service called DIRECTV Wireless High Speed Internet to DIRECTV customers in specific ZIP codes in the Anaheim, CA, area beginning in mid-September. We expect to provide DIRECTV Broadband in other cities, too, but we haven’t announced any rollout plans yet. As for details and commitment requirements, I wouldn’t want to speculate about pricing, availability or commitment requirements until we’re ready to offer the service in your area, but stay tuned and we’ll contact you when DIRECTV Broadband is available in Nashville TN.
“Even though the new service isn’t available to you right now, we’ve also partnered with leading DSL providers Earthlink, Verizon, Qwest and BellSouth to offer affordable high-speed Internet solutions to customers across the nation. Please visit our website at directv.com/DSL for more information on these exciting services or call us at 1-800-720-4926.”
I still don’t know why the company can’t install the TV/Internet satellite antenna on Luster Road since they can do it less than six miles away. There may be a technical reason, but DIRECTTV reps either can’t or won’t reveal ‘em.
It’s sort of like the Jerry Seinfeld joke about airplane pilots who say they’re going to fly faster and make up lost time. The planes are in the air and there are no traffic cops around, so why aren’t they putting the pedal to the metal all the time?
As for DIRECTV’s satellite Internet/TV dish, you install it on a house and hook it up. It points at the sky. There’s sky at my house, so why can’t I get the service?
Anyway, by the time you read this, I will have satellite Internet at my house—thanks to HughesNet. Check in at Macsimum tomorrow for the first in my series of articles on using satellite Internet on a Mac.
As for DIRECTV’s “Macsimum rating,” what else can I give it up 0 out of 10?
Rodney Says:
I believe the FCC prohibits ‘self installs’ of internet satellite dishes, because they contain transmitters. The majority of Direct tv’s normal installation contractors may not have the required certifications.
Posted on January 22, 2007
Jim Says:
DirectTV is test marketing. It is not that they can’t provide service in TN, they want to see if it will be profitable first. BTW, Anahiem was the headquarters of Hughes, the originator of DirectTV. Unless you live in a cave, heavy forest, or the poles, satellite service is a possibility. Just expect it to be expensive due to the cost of uplink transmitters.
In other words, just as with DSL, you are not, at this time, a big enough market to serve. The technical issues are rather straight forward. The real issue is money and profitability.
Posted on January 22, 2007
Jon Says:
I’m a DirecTV subscriber and considering that DirecTV’s former satellite internet service (DirectWay) became HughesNet, it’s a surprise they’re rollling out another such service. We once considered DirecWay because of a situation similar to yours. We ended up going with a local “wireless broadband” provider and have been more than happy with them for about 3 years.
Nothing’s changed in our area, but for some reason, DSL is now available.
Rodney said, “I believe the FCC prohibits ‘self installs’ of internet satellite dishes, because they contain transmitters.” I think he is mistaken at least as far as the former DirecWay (now HughesNet) setup is concerned. Their dishes were receivers only and I believe this is how HughesNet and all satellite internet providers work. DirecWay’s service was high speed in only one direction, downstream. You still required a phone line.
Posted on January 22, 2007
Steven Friedrich Says:
Forget satellite. You’ll hate the latency and you’ll hate the bandwidth caps. Do what I did; swallow hard and then pony up for a real T1. (It beats commuting!) Here’s a fine outfit with a great price. I’m even thinking about switching from my current provider (@ $650/mo) to them (@ $399/mo).
http://www.speakeasy.net/promos/fatpipe/
Posted on January 22, 2007
Randy Says:
Just go with EVDO (sprint or verizon).You’ll have broadband acess with speeds quicker than Hughesnet.With Sprint you can download all you want,but with verizon (even though they call it “unlimited") they will terminate service if you consistantly go over the limit.
Posted on January 24, 2007
Eideard Says:
Jon—D* got rid of the phone line uplink so long ago I’d practically forgotten about it. Dude, something beside blogs. :)
Posted on January 25, 2007
Article Information
Comment on this Article Print this Article Email this Article Digg This
Contributor
Dennis Sellers
Dennis has been a newspaper editor/reporter (seven years) and teacher (seven years). He has over 4,000 magazine, newspaper and online articles to his credit. He has also covered the Mac and tech industries for over a decade for such online publications as MacCentral, MacMinute and now MacsimumNews.







Steve Says:
That’s funny! I can hear you saying, “I live on planet earth, in the North America sector” Did you try to get satellite radio yet?
Posted on January 22, 2007